October 19, 2021

Opinion: Washington Capitals five biggest changes needed for 2014-15

The Washington Capitals missed the playoffs for the first time since 2007. There wasn’t enough talent on hand, the talent available was mismanaged and there was discord between the front office and the on-ice staff. Missing the playoffs should finally be motivation to make the changes necessary for the Caps to truly contend for the Stanley Cup.

Here are the five biggest changes needed by the Caps as they enter what could be offseason full of change and drama.

1) Settle the General Manager and coaching situations.

It’s widely rumored that GM George McPhee’s contract expires following the NHL Draft. Adam Oates has another year on his contract. There’s plenty of evidence (Martin Erat, Dustin Penner, Dmitry Orlov, the goaltending situation, Tom Wilson) that McPhee and Oates’ talent evaluation doesn’t mesh. Somewhere between Ted Leonsis, President Dick Patrick and McPhee, the Caps need to decide who’s going to be in charge of this latest reboot. [By the time you read this on Monday, changes may already have been made.]

Oates’ insistence on players skating on their strong side has handicapped the organization. He’s tried to switch wingers to center (Martin Erat, Eric Fehr) and centers to wingers (Mikhail Grabovski). He played the world’s greatest goal scorer with Jay Beagle as his center on purpose. He’s banished players that were traded for by McPhee to the point of rendering them useless. His systems are indecipherable. In short, the Caps have been a disaster on the ice, much less than the sum of their parts. That falls on Oates.

McPhee is far from blameless. In fact, the collection of defensemen McPhee provided for Oates to employ this season was embarrassing, After the top combo of Karl Alzner and John Carlson, every single defenseman the Caps played this year was flawed. Mike Green isn’t nearly the offensive weapon he was during his back-to-back Norris Trophy finalist days. He still drives play, but his defensive shortcomings and gaffes often lead to bad goals. Orlov is a work in progress — talented, but raw and impetuous. The rest simply aren’t yet, or are no longer, NHL caliber. And it’s been like that the entirety of Ovechkin’s illustrious career. That falls on McPhee.

Either or both could be replaced for 2014-15, and it’s imperative the Capitals figure it out before the draft.

2) Seriously upgrade the defense.

People have said for years the Caps need a “stay-at-home” defenseman, responsible for shutting down opponents’ top lines. But the problem lies deeper than that. The Alzner/Carlson duo are good, but not great. They are a No. 1 pairing in name only. That results in a trickle-down effect. The Caps have some young talent (Orlov, Connor Carrick, Patrick Wey, Madison Bowey), but only Orlov is really close enough to the NHL level to contribute meaningfully next season, despite the experience Carrick gained this season.

The Capitals need to acquire 2-3 legitimate NHL defensemen, including a puck mover. If they can acquire a true top-pairing defenseman — probably via trade — they should do all they can to make that happen, then fill in the other spots with veteran free agents.

3) Improve play at 5v5.

The Caps were one of the worst teams in the league in puck possession, and has gotten consistently worse throughout Oates’ tenure. The team is lackadaisical and sloppy in its own end, the breakouts are unorganized, team defense suffers from lack of structure and focus, not to mention talent level.

One of the biggest problems for the Caps is one of the simplest: attempting to exit their own zone with the puck. Oates and Calle Johansson have instructed the defensemen to get rid of the puck within a second and a half of gaining possession. The idea is that if the puck is being passed, the defensemen aren’t putting themselves in danger of having their head separated from their bodies. While those instructions might have provided better health for some of their blueliners, it also neutralizes much of what makes those players effective.

Mike Green, John Carlson, Dmitry Orlov — hell, even Jack Hillen — are puck-moving defensemen. McPhee drafted or obtained these players with the idea that these guys are strong skaters and can carry the puck out of the defensive zone and through the neutral zone, therefore setting up the offense.

But Oates’ and Johansson’s instructions to chip the puck to the neutral zone has instead stymied the offense. Wingers now have to battle for pucks in the neutral zone instead of setting up the attack. Instead of even attempting “dump and chase”, the Caps end up playing “dump and change”, so tired from fighting puck battles that they have to dump and go for a line change.

Either the players or the system has to change.

4) Reduce the team’s salary burden ever further.

McPhee did a great job at the trade deadline to reduce the Caps salary constraints next season by dealing Martin Erat and Michal Neuvirth. He — or whoever will be in charge — should go even further by buying out Brooks Laich (pending health) and/or trading Mike Green.

The Caps already have a good deal of cap space next season, currently $14.2 million. But Laich accounts for $4.5 million against the cap and Green’s hit is a staggering $6.083 million. Neither player is anywhere near what they were when they signed the deals.

Laich was — emphasis was — a 20-goal scoring two-way player. He was equally adept on the power play as he was on the penalty kill. He could fill a center or winger role on a scoring or checking line. But a groin injury sustained while playing abroad during the lockout has destroyed his past two seasons. When he has been able to take the ice, he’s been completely ineffective.

Green was — emphasis was — a two-time Norris Trophy candidate. He possessed singular skill at the position, producing back-to-back 70 point seasons. But again, accumulation of injury (concussions, groin, shoulder) has reduced Green to a shell of the player he once was. His nine goal, 29 assist season wasn’t bad, but the production pales in comparison to the expectation — or paycheck.

Buying out Laich and trading Green would free up another $10 million plus against the cap, giving the Capitals even more flexibility to go about rebuilding this team.

5) Inspire and motivate Alex Ovechkin — or trade him.

Alex Ovechkin is the most valuable asset the Washington Capitals possess. He registered 51 goals in 13-14, but had one 5v5 goal in the last two dozen games. Some of that has to do with Oates’ curious choices for his linemates, some of it was the result of the Caps’ systems, and some of it lies with Ovechkin himself.

His revitalization the past two seasons has occurred on the strength of the Caps prodigious power play. But the team’s inability to drive play at 5v5 has crippled any chance of this team to be successful. While Ovechkin has never played defense with the enthusiasm he utilizes on offense, at times this season he showed open disdain playing in his own end.

Ovechkin himself said the team pays him to score goals. That much is true. But it also pays him to sell tickets and the brand. And he can’t do that cruising through the neutral zone while his man streaks through the slot en route to another goal. This organization has to find a way to motivate Ovechkin to at least make consistent effort in playing defense. He doesn’t even have to be good at it. But as the captain of the team, he at least has to look like he’s trying.

At this point, Ovechkin is part of the problem. No, he isn’t going to be confused for a Selke finalist. But as captain, he needs to be more involved in all aspects of the game. He needs to show effort in every facet of his game. He needs to be a leader. It’s always been said that Ovechkin is a “lead by example” type of leader. Right now, the example he’s setting to Evgeny Kuznetsov and other young players is that defense and accountability doesn’t matter — that he’s above the rules. That’s not acceptable.

It’s simply not enough for Ovechkin to score 50 goals for this team. If it was, they’d have won multiple Cups by now as Ted Leonsis promised they would. If Ovechkin isn’t able or willing to invest the requisite effort to provide a better example to follow, then the organization should seriously consider trading him to a team where he wouldn’t have to carry that burden.

About Dave Nichols

Dave Nichols is Editor-in-Chief of District Sports Page. He is credentialed to cover the Washington Nationals, Capitals, Wizards and Mystics. Dave also covers national college football and basketball and Major League Soccer for Associated Press and is a copy editor for the Spokesman-Review newspaper in Spokane, WA. He spent four years in radio covering the Baltimore Orioles, Washington Redskins and the University of Maryland football and basketball teams. Dave is a life-long D.C. sports fan and attended his first pro game in 1974 — the Caps’ second game in existence. You can follow him on Twitter @DaveNicholsDSP


  1. Steve Repsher says:

    Bravo, Dave. All the points are spot-on. Most Caps fans won’t want to hear such harsh criticism of their faves — especially Ovi and Green — but the regressed play of those two is clear as day.

    A quick point-by-point response:

    1) Oates has to go. For the better part of the last 2 months, that opinion was followed by “and GMGM cannot be the one to pick the next coach.” But I’ve backed down from that. Oates’ ‘system’ and beliefs make it almost impossible to find 18 skaters who can make that way work in the NHL. To have that much disdain for McPhee’s acquisitions and have such a different idea on what the team needs has to be resolved. I can see GM sitting back and wondering “What am I supposed to do for this guy?”

    Then again, this is the McPhee who hired Bruce Cassidy. This is the McPhee who over-reacted after getting Halak’ed in the playoffs. He’s not without blame, either.

    2) Yup. 74 and 27 can stay. Orlov is still worth the investment of time to see where he’ll wind up. Every last one of the rest of ‘em are too far removed from being a contributory member of the D-corps — either it’s way too soon or way too late. Green’s always been a one-trick pony and there was a time when that trick was special. But now, in the words of Agent J in ‘Men in Black’, that trick is “old and busted.” It’s certainly not worth $6 million.

    3) No team can be that reliant an a portion of the attack that’s on the ice for 8-12 minutes each game.

    4) Well stated. Laich’s fans won’t want to hear that either. The time has come where we can’t ask them to hang on to the players we like. We have to ask for the players this team needs so that we’re not in this same spot a year from now.

    5) Touche. It’s bothersome to think that anyone can be so singularly focused. What happened to the Ovechkin that would hit practically anything that moved? He’s won the Richard Trophy, which means he gets to go to Vegas, get dressed up and be part of the spotlight — which seems to be all he cares about now. Oh, he also cares about getting on yet another Russian national team. They hadn’t even turned off the lights on the jumbo video screen and Ovechkin was already lining up a flight to Minsk.

    This is the Capitals’ most important offseason in more than 10 years. It won’t be boring.

    • “What happened to the Ovechkin that would hit practically anything that moved? ”

      He got suspended by the NHL– sometimes fairly, and some rather more borderline, considering the inconsistent treatment of other repeat offendors– and had it beaten in to him that he was not going to be given the benefit of the doubt when it came to physical play. So, he backed off to stop getting punished for it.

      I find your entire paragraph here regarding Ovechkin and what he cares about to be just a dumb statement and without basis. Ovechkin has reported to Russia for their national team every time they’ve asked him, after every post-season exit, even when he was injured. Why wouldn’t he report now? What else does he have to do in DC? Why would you get on his case for going back to his home country? As much as I care about Ovechkin on the Capitals and representing my home city’s team, he clearly feels pride and loyalty to his home country (even when they’ve thrown him under the bus) and I can’t fault him for that. In fact, I respect him more for it.

      Think of where the Capitals would be this season without Ovechkin, considering the percentage of goals he scored for the team. Through interviews this season, he has repeatedly credited his teammates and coaches for being the reason he’s reached over fifty goals– certainly the behavior of a player who only craves the spotlight, I guess. At his exit interview, he refused to blame the coaches or system, saying the onus is on the players and on himself. So, basically, you’re wrong to fault him for only wanting the spotlight and taking part in his country’s national team after his season has ended. It amazes me how fans will basically demand a player be publicly miserable and grovel just to satisfy their own disappointment.

      Is he perfect? No. Are there things he can improve on? Of course. But I’m thankful I get to watch a a generational talent of a player be on my team night in and night out, and I think fans in DC are spoiled because of how high our expectations are– we expect him to be perfect and amazing every single night and that’s just not possible for any player.


  1. […] USA TODAY Sports. USA Today. by Kevin Allen, USA TODAY Sports. Filed Under. USA Today …Opinion: Washington Capitals five biggest changes needed for 2014-15District Sports Page'They've got to get better. I've got to get better'Comcast […]

%d bloggers like this: