June 22, 2018

Washington Capitals new coach must win over players, skepitcal fan base

Around lunchtime Tuesday, the word was already getting out. The typical national media types were reporting that the Washington Capitals were going to hire Adam Oates as their new head coach, replacing Dale Hunter, who decided to go back to London, Ontario to be with his family, farm and resume the mantel of coaching the OHL Knights, which he co-owns with his brother.

It’s funny, but whenever there are leaks on big news coming from the Caps, it always seems to come from the big names in the national scene, like Darren Dreger, Nick Kypreos or Bob McKenzie.

Regardless, at 1:24 pm the Caps sent out a press release confirming the rumors that Oates would indeed take over as bench boss of the Caps. Oates was one of the finest playmakers in the history of the league, ranked sixth all-time in assists. He was known as a heady player during his 19-year career and it seems like Oates has made a natural transition into the coaching ranks upon his retirement.

Before we get into his bona fides, there are two complaints making the rounds about Oates before he’s even been introduced to the D.C. media:

  1. He’s never been a head coach anywhere, let alone in the NHL
  2. He’s the second straight ex-Caps player hired without NHL head coaching experience

As for the first point, sure, you’d probably like to have a guy that has been “the guy” before. But then again, if that guy is available, you have to wonder to yourself, why isn’t he still “the guy” with somebody else? As for the second, if you think George McPhee is hiring a head coach at such a critical time in the organization’s history as a public relations stunt, you’re deluded. It may have factored into the decision in a background sort of way, but let’s give McPhee a little credit, shall we?

Look, nobody knows what kind of head coach Oates is going to be because he doesn’t know right now either. But there have been plenty of NHL head coaches that didn’t have that experience and turned out pretty good (see: Bylsma, Dan for one prime example). And Oates’ familiarity with the organization could be seen as a plus in that he’s familiar with McPhee, owner Ted Leonsis and the market.

What we can assume from his playing style, interviews throughout the industry including current players and former teammates, and his admittedly limited coaching resume is that Oates will play a more up-tempo style of offense than his immediate predecessor while still emphasizing an overall balanced game plan.

So let’s then take a look at his resume and imagine we’re talking about someone not named “Adam Oates”.

  1. One of the league’s premier playmakers throughout his 19-year NHL career
  2. Widely respected assistant coach on this past season’s Eastern Conference Stanley Cup runner-up
  3. Credited for turning around moribund power play for said Stanley Cup finalists
  4. Also credited for bolstering the penalty kill and being a very good communicator in practice and on the bench
  5. Previous assistant for another conference foe with a good power play
  6. Oh, by the way, elected to the Hockey Hall of Fame an hour after being announced Caps head coach

What, exactly, is not to like about that?

Adam Oates will get a chance to coach what is still a very talented, though flawed, team. If he has the same success with the Caps on the power play as he did with the Devils, that in and of itself would go a long way in fixing what’s broken on this team. It will be interesting to see who they bring in as assistant coaches. It will be fascinating to see how Oates interacts with his star players, notably Alex Ovechkin.

Most of all, though, it should be enjoyable for fans to get to know the new head coach, either for the first time or all over again, and see what he can do. After a year of turmoil, disappointment, ugly hockey and another second round flameout, we could all use a little optimism.

Sadly, there are plenty of “fans” that would rather be right above all else, even if that means their team not winning. How ’bout we give the new guy a chance before calling for his head?


Dave Nichols is Editor-in-Chief of District Sports Page. He is credentialed to cover the Nats and the Caps, and previously wrote Nats News Network and Caps News Network. Dave’s first sports hero was Bobby Dandridge. Follow Dave’s Capitals coverage on Twitter @CapitalsDSP.

About Dave Nichols

Dave Nichols is Editor-in-Chief of District Sports Page. He is credentialed to cover the Washington Nationals, Capitals, Wizards and Mystics. Dave also covers national college football and basketball and Major League Soccer for Associated Press and is a copy editor for the Spokesman-Review newspaper in Spokane, WA. He spent four years in radio covering the Baltimore Orioles, Washington Redskins and the University of Maryland football and basketball teams. Dave is a life-long D.C. sports fan and attended his first pro game in 1974 — the Caps’ second game in existence. You can follow him on Twitter @DaveNicholsDSP


  1. Scott Gater says:

    It will be fun to watch the TSN and CBC crowd all second guess this hiring. He’s served a good apprentice with NJ, and he deserves a chance to succeed. It is a little funny that the last two coaches are Cap alumni and that they were made head coach first, rather then moving them up the system.
    Considering how well NJ did of turning themselves around from being known as a boring to watch team to and exciting to watch team, I think Mr. Oates has promise.
    However, I would disagree with the premise that being a good playmaker make a good coach- ie. Gretzky in Phoenix.

    • I don’t care about being right. I care about this team FINALLY hoisting the Cup. I am sick of inexperienced head coaches.
      Like I said, I don’t care about being right. And in this case, I hope I am very wrong. But my gut instinct tells me this another mistake in a long line of them for McPhee.

      Btw, I noticed you put fans in parenthesis. Because obviously any fan that questions this team’s moves or it’s intent must not be a “true” fan. Unlike a lot of people, I have been a fan for 17 years. Unlike some “fans” I have sat in a near empty Verizon Center, long before Boudreau became the coach and Caps games were the in thing to do.

      • Dave Nichols says:

        well Robert, then that last paragraph doesn’t refer to you then, eh? I don’t understand why you’re so upset. everyone’s entitled to their opinion and welcome to voice it here. other than Oates’ lack of experience as an NHL head coach and your gut instinct, do you have any other reasons why you’re against the hire? who was your prefered candidate and why? i’m happy to have a discussion about this, but just going “gut instinct” doesn’t leave me much to debate.

        thanks for taking the time to comment.

%d bloggers like this: